In numerous interviews Lykke Li
has admitted that the only album she owned when growing up was Madonna’s Immaculate Collection. From this, then, you might expect her debut album, Youth Novels to consist of 80s electronica
beats, quirky pop choruses and lots of lyrics about sex. There's electronica a plenty, but Youth Novels takes
more of an influence from the Madonna of recent years (awful current album
excluded).
This is a slinky, smart record, cluttered with multiple instruments
and many, many musical influences. Youth
Novels is an album of contradictions, managing to be electronica, folk and straight out pop all at once, buoyant and morose, cheerful and sombre.
It's at its most poppy that Youth Novels works best. Lead
single I’m Good, I’m Gone is simple, catchy electro pop music at its very
best with Li’s breathy, childlike voice sounding super sassy against a pounding piano melody
and heavy bass line. It’s in perfect keeping with the tale of a woman who has
ditched the no-good boyfriend (you’ll be calling but I won’t be at the phone
Li chants). The track is by far the best moment on the album.
Other similar tracks, however,
come close. Dance, Dance, Dance similarly mixes Li’s raspy vocals with a
light yet hypnotic beat,
boasting some very weird and wonderful instrumentation. Complaint Department with its dark and strange subject matter, is also captivating, yet relies more on beats and is the most dance orientated track on the album. Li offers up the revengeful taunts of an abused lover making it far from poppy, but this is no bad thing. It is a sexy,
rhythmic number, and the most sophisticated track here.
However, Li’s signature style of
mixing her hushed, breathy vocals with heavy, primitive beats, can, at times,
become overbearing. The formula is used just a few too many times on the album
and ceases have the punch it does on the very best tracks. Let It Fall
suffers in it's place just after Dance, Dance, Dance and I’m Good, I’m
Gone and sounds boring in comparison. Hanging High, despite its ethereal,
dreamlike quality is a definite album slump and just can't stand up to the rest of the album. On Time Flies the heavy piano makes the
song almost hymnal, but Li’s vocals are childish rather than childlike – at
times her voice filters off, a quality I'm sure the listener is supposed to
find endearing and authentic, but instead it begins to grate.
The good news, though, is that
there are enough other tracks on the album that are different, eccentric, and at
times, brilliant. My Love is a simple ballad, reminiscent of the
Beach Boys at their best with its summery, lolloping melody and gorgeous vocal
harmonies. Tonight, a pleading and urgent love song, manages to be as moving as
anything Mariah has ever sang, despite Li’s unusual singing style.
Little Bit drifts with soft beats and is similar in style to the likes of Hot Chip and Rafter, mixing Li’s childlike vocals with some pretty direct lyrics (For you I’d keep my
legs apart). Li manages to sound almost angry on album closer Window Blues
and even experiments with rap on the album’s most overtly R & B track, Everybody but Me. Two of the tracks are spoken word - album opener Melodies
and Desires, a repetitive, hypnotic poem with an ethereal feel and the minute
and a half long This Trumpet In My Head.
Youth Novels, then, is a pure, simple, and at times incredibly
effective pop album. At her best Lykke Li is nothing short of outstanding, but she
does overuse the formula to the point where some tracks suffocate, and
the album suffers from this. However, there is enough variety here to make Youth Novels a very solid debut, and
well worth a listen. Just don’t buy if you don’t like breathy vocals.